
A Value Creation Story
If you left your company today, what would leave with you? Your title would be gone. Your authority would be gone. The products, resources, pricing power, and credibility of the company would stay behind. Your customers would get someone new.
So here’s the question: Would they still call you?
Not to congratulate you on the new job or simply to stay connected. Would they call because your perspective, judgment, or counsel still mattered even though you could no longer sell them anything?
Early in my career at Coca-Cola North America, I got an answer to that question years before I knew enough to ask it.
I Was There to Sell Beverages
I was responsible for restaurant customers across the Ohio marketplace. One of my most significant customers was East of Chicago Pizza, a growing pizza chain headquartered in Willard, Ohio. The owner was Scott.
The assignment was pretty straightforward. Coca-Cola wanted an exclusive, multi-year beverage agreement. Our primary competitor wanted the business. Scott wanted the best financial deal he could negotiate. Everybody understood why we were sitting at the table.
I represented Coca-Cola. That mattered. The brand opened doors. The resources behind me mattered. The economics mattered. But the more time I spent with Scott and his team, the more I realized something: the thing I was there to sell wasn’t the biggest problem he needed to solve.
Scott had a relatively young team. He was trying to grow his company, and he needed his people to grow with it. Developing that team was far more consequential to his business than which beverage logo appeared on the fountain equipment.
I knew something about developing people. I knew something about marketing, management, and leadership. So I started helping.
We held several training sessions with Scott’s team. Most had very little to do with Coca-Cola. Nobody at Coke told me to do it. There wasn’t a provision in the contract requiring it. And I wasn’t disguising a product presentation as leadership development.
Scott had a problem, and I had something that might help. So I shared what I knew. I wasn’t thinking about value creation selling. I certainly wasn’t calculating the ROI on the time I was investing in his people. I was trying to help Scott win.
Somewhere along the way, something changed. I was still the Coca-Cola guy. I still had a contract to negotiate. But I had become useful beyond what I was selling.
Then I Left
Scott and I eventually negotiated the multi-year agreement. Coca-Cola kept the business. Scott got terms that worked for his company, and Coca-Cola got terms that worked for ours.
If the story ended there, this would be a nice sales story. Help the customer. Build trust. Get the contract.
Except I eventually left the account.
I moved into other responsibilities inside Coca-Cola. Scott got a new account team. They owned the relationship now. They had the products, the resources, the pricing authority, and the Coca-Cola name behind them. Everything Scott needed from Coca-Cola stayed with Coca-Cola, including the responsibility for negotiating the next contract.
Years passed. Eventually, the agreement Scott and I had negotiated came up for renewal. The new account team did what good account teams do. They prepared. They worked the economics. They developed the proposal. They negotiated.
The deal moved toward completion. Then, before Scott signed the new agreement, he had one request.
He wanted to talk to Galen Bingham.
I wasn’t his account manager anymore. I wasn’t part of the negotiating team. I wasn’t going to receive credit for the sale. I had no pricing authority. I had nothing left to sell him.
But he still called.
That’s the part of this story that has stayed with me for more than three decades. The first contract told me we had made a deal. That call told me we had created something that survived my departure.
There’s a difference.
What Was the Value?
Companies know how to measure transactions. I spent enough years carrying numbers to know that firsthand. Revenue. Margin. Volume. Market share. Contract value. Profitability. Those measurements matter.
But tell me where this goes on the spreadsheet: Years after you leave the account, the customer still wants your counsel before making the next decision.
What was that worth?
The time I spent developing Scott’s team helped us earn the first contract. I believe the relationship we built influenced the next agreement too. But the second contract didn’t make the original investment valuable.
If Scott had eventually chosen our competitor, the time I spent helping his people would not suddenly have become worthless. His team still developed. Scott still received help solving a problem that mattered to his business. The second contract simply gave me evidence that the value had endured.
That’s important because value creation isn’t generosity with a hidden invoice attached. If I only help you because I expect the favor to come back to me, that’s still a transaction. I’ve just extended the payment terms.
Sometimes the economic return is immediate. Sometimes it comes years later. Sometimes you may never see it. In Scott’s case, I got to see something rare.
I left. The value didn’t.
Some Things Should Be Transactions
I don’t want to romanticize this. Not every exchange needs a relationship attached to it.
I once bought a rug in Tangier, Morocco. Well, technically, my wife wanted the rug. I was apparently responsible for the negotiation. Now that called for transactional negotiation at its finest.
The merchant had a rug. My wife wanted the rug. He wanted as much of my money as he could reasonably get. I wanted to keep as much of my money as I reasonably could. Nobody was building a strategic partnership. I wasn’t helping him develop his employees. I’m pretty sure he wasn’t concerned about my leadership trajectory.
We negotiated until we reached a number where he was willing to let the rug go and I was willing to carry it home. Everybody understood the assignment.
Some exchanges are transactions. Treat them like transactions. But know which exchange you’re actually in. Don’t force a relationship onto a transaction. And don’t reduce a relationship to a transaction.
What Are You Trying to Solve?
Transactional selling tends to begin with one question: What am I trying to sell?
Value creation begins somewhere else: What are you trying to solve?
Once I understand your real problem, I can determine whether I can honestly help. Sometimes I can. Sometimes I can’t. If I can’t, I should have enough integrity to say so. Because if I’m more committed to getting your money than solving your problem, I’m not creating value. I’m extracting it.
If I can help, then we can have a different conversation. What is the problem already costing you? What happens if nothing changes? What becomes possible if we solve it? Ultimately, what is it worth to no longer have this problem?
Now price has context. Price is what changes hands. Value is what changes because of the exchange.
What Started as Instinct Became Expertise
Years after Scott, Coca-Cola put me in charge of reimagining its global selling process. Think about that progression. I went from trying to create value for one restaurant customer in Willard, Ohio, to helping shape how one of the world’s most recognized companies approached selling. I eventually taught selling and negotiation across the United States, Canada, Mexico, and England.
What started as instinct became expertise. The customers got bigger. The stakes got higher. The negotiations became more complex. The question didn’t: What is the customer actually trying to solve?
Understand the real problem. Determine whether you can genuinely help solve it. Create value. Then have an adult conversation about what that value is worth.
That’s selling to me.
The Product Changed. The Principle Didn’t.
Today, I’m no longer selling beverages. I work with senior executives and organizations facing problems, opportunities, and decisions with real consequences.
Pressure may be narrowing an executive’s perspective. A leadership team may be avoiding the conversation that needs to happen. An accomplished leader may be navigating power, politics, complexity, and competing priorities.
My first responsibility isn’t to sell.
My first responsibility is to see.
Can I help you see something you couldn’t see before? Can that expanded perspective improve the judgment you bring to the decision? Can we create an outcome worth more than the investment required to engage me?
If yes, let’s talk. If not, I shouldn’t take the money.
Different work. Same principle.
If You Leave Today
So I’ll give the question back to you: If you leave today, would your customers still call?
Your company may have introduced you. Your title may have given you access. Your product may have given you a reason to meet. Your authority may have made your calls worth returning. But what have you created?
When all of that stays behind, is there anything about your perspective, judgment, experience, or contribution that the customer would still value?
That’s the test. Not whether they remember you, like you, or follow you. Would they still call when you can no longer do anything for them except be valuable?
Scott did.
Years after I left the account, my name still meant something. That’s value creation.
And maybe that’s a better way to think about reputation too. Your reputation isn’t simply who knows your name. It’s what your name means when you’re not in the room.
For years, I could have asked, What was that time worth? Today, I think that’s the wrong question.
The better question is: How could I possibly have afforded not to spend it?
Something to Consider:
1. If you leave today, what value stays behind? Beyond the sales, projects, deliverables, and numbers, what is better because you were there? What did you build, teach, strengthen, or change that continues without you?
2. If your title, company, and authority disappeared today, why would a customer still call you? Take away everything the institution lends you. What’s left? What perspective, judgment, expertise, or counsel have you developed that has value independent of the logo on your business card?
3. What does your name mean when you’re not in the room? Not how many people know it or how impressive your title sounds. When someone mentions your name and you’re nowhere around, what have your actions taught people to expect from you?
Consider This
#ValueCreation #SalesLeadership #ExecutiveCoaching #CustomerRelationships #PowerIsBuiltNeverGranted



